News and Events
This Southern Town Was Growing So Fast, It Passed a Ban on Growth; Residents, most of whom came from out of state, are fed up with crowded roads and schools and boil-water advisories
Swikar Patel for The Wall Street Journal. Wall Street Journal (Online); New York, N.Y. [New York, N.Y] 03 Feb 2020.
February 3, 2020
LAKE WYLIE, S.C.—This lakefront suburb of Charlotte, N.C., is among the Sunbelt's strongest magnets for young families.
Since 2000, Lake Wylie has tripled in population to 12,000 on the strength of its good schools, low taxes and proximity to Charlotte's jobs in the financial and technology sectors. But those schools are filling up, the water system frequently fails under increased demand and 20-mile commutes are stretching to 90 minutes.
Now, the town that grew too fast wants to stop growth.
In December, the York County Council, which is led by Republicans, put a 16-month moratorium on commercial and residential rezoning requests and consideration of any new apartment complexes or subdivisions. It is the most comprehensive ban so far in a state where fast-growing cities are temporarily blocking everything from dollar stores to student housing, the Municipal Association of South Carolina said.
"People say, 'You're a business owner. Why do you want to stop growth?'" said York County Councilmember Allison Love, a Republican who owns a jewelry store. "But we've passed the point of diminishing returns."
Ms. Love collected thousands of signatures in support of a slowdown, some at community meetings she hosted during rush hour, thinking constituents would attend rather than be stuck in traffic.
She said Lake Wylie has been filling up with gas stations and look-alike subdivisions ("I call them 'Whovilles'") with no plan for what type of development is needed. There are seven car washes and six self-storage facilities along the town's main artery, but few restaurants and doctors' offices.
"It's like getting in the cafeteria line and you said, 'OK, you got baked fish, spaghetti,' so you take some, then you get down the line and say, 'Oh, that fried chicken looks good,' and then you get to the end and you don't have room for the banana pudding," Ms. Love said. "We don't have room for the banana pudding."
Booming towns across the Sunbelt are struggling to unwind the unintended consequences of growth. After years of taking a hands-off approach, they now find themselves without the tax structures or long-term infrastructure plans needed to deal with the present and help shape their future.
More than 80% of Lake Wylie's population was born in another state and 40% of its households have school-age children, according to the U.S. Census.
The local school district is seeking to pay for at least three new schools with a $15,000 impact fee applied to the cost of a newly built house. The Clover School District, which includes Lake Wylie, modeled its proposal on the neighboring Fort Mill School District, which saw a slowdown in construction after raising its fee two years ago to $18,000 from $2,500.
The Home Builders Association of South Carolina and a coalition of other builders are challenging the Fort Mill school fee in a lawsuit, saying it is so "excessive it shocks the conscience" and four times the national average of $4,700. The median list price for a home in Lake Wylie is $344,000, according to Realtor.com.
The Lake Wylie Chamber of Commerce supports the measures as a "pause" for local government to catch up.
"It's all happened so quickly," Chamber President Susan Bromfield said. "You want growth, but you want planned growth."
Sara McCauley fears it is too little, too late. She said her family fled "a life on pavement" in a small rental house in San Jose, Calif., in 2011 for a five-bedroom house a stone's throw from the lake. Since then, her husband's commute time doubled, her child's class size has grown to 26 from 20 and the water system has failed so frequently that she stockpiles gallons of store-bought water.
"We are sick of the traffic and constant construction and water main breaks," said Ms. McCauley, a 42-year-old mother of three. "Everything is just behind."
For decades, Lake Wylie was a sleepy home to a summer camp and family fishing cabins in forested coves linked by gravel roads.
Over the years, the city of Charlotte gradually sprawled into South Carolina, with houses sprouting up on both sides of Lake Wylie, which straddles the state line. The banking-based Charlotte economy stalled after the downturn but has since boomed, adding 50,000 jobs in the past five years.
At the same time, the towns on the South Carolina side also boomed, as the administration of former Gov. Nikki Haley used tax breaks to attract businesses from Charlotte and elsewhere to York County. They brought thousands of employees with them to communities like Lake Wylie, where the median household income is $87,750, about 70% higher than the state average of $51,015.
In the mid-2000s, legislators cut South Carolina's residential property tax roughly in half, making the comparatively low cost-of-living even more appealing to millennial workers seeking first homes.
Kimber Weaver, 38, said her family moved from the North Carolina side of the lake in 2014, drawn by schools and property taxes that were half the rate she paid on the other side of the lake.
Her husband, an attorney in uptown Charlotte, traded a 30-minute commute for one that takes 35-minutes, at least at first. They bought a 3,600 square-foot house in a neighborhood with a pool and many young families.
Ms. Weaver said she first noticed Lake Wylie's growing pains a few years ago when neighbors warned her to get on the wait list for day care a year before her toddler needed it. She adjusted her schedule as a local hairdresser until she could secure a spot, then adjusted it again as her husband's commute to uptown Charlotte on Interstate 77 stretched to more than an hour.
Ms. Weaver recently dropped her longtime pharmacy to avoid bumper-to-bumper traffic on one of Lake Wylie's few arterial roads. She pulled her daughter out of gymnastics because it took 40 minutes to travel 3 miles home.
"I was just like, 'I can't do this anymore,' " she said. "The growth affects what we do every day."
Many residents say they haven't saved as much money as they expected by moving to Lake Wylie because a monthly water-and-sewer bill runs $115. The state median is $57 a month, according to an analysis by the Environmental Finance Center at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The rate would rise to $177 a month if state regulators approve a rate increase sought by Blue Granite Water Co., a private company that has a long-term contract to operate the water system.
The overtaxed system is a vestige of York County's rural history, with a patchwork of providers buying from the central water system in the city of Rock Hill. Lake Wylie residents have also been under boil-water advisories a dozen times in the past two years. They were blocked for five months last summer from watering lawns, washing cars and filling pools, with patrols out at night looking for scofflaws.
Blue Granite had a 40% increase in demand for water from 2014 to 2019, according to Catherine Heigel, who runs Blue Granite Water Co. as an executive with the Corix Group of Companies.
Ms. Heigel said the rate hike would cover increased costs from municipal suppliers and help pay for infrastructure investment, including a new pipeline carrying water from Charlotte.
"It's extremely rapid growth and it is growth that the county has not kept up with," she said. "We've become the unfortunate scapegoat for some of this stuff."
York County Planning Manager Diane Dil said one goal during the moratorium on growth is to figure out what goes where in the remaining undeveloped areas. Another goal is coming up with a roads plan to connect neighborhoods and towns to one another, rather than relying on state highways and Interstate 77. In the spring, the Lake Wylie Recreation Park will open, with soccer fields, walking trails and a community hall that the county sees as a de facto town center.
It isn't clear whether a moratorium will have the intended effect. There are more than 3,000 homes and apartments approved for Lake Wylie that are in various stages of construction.
Rob Salvino, a pro-growth economist at Coastal Carolina University in Conway, S.C., said moratoria interfere with markets and are no substitute for planning.
"Growth is happening in the Sunbelt," he said. "It's more a question of, 'Are you going to admit that it's coming and work to try to make it the best we can?'"
Ms. Dil said it is important that local leaders move quickly to relieve congestion, corral growth and recapture Lake Wylie's small-town feel.
Ms. McCauley, who moved here from San Jose, is leaving later this month. Her husband took a job in Boston and will telecommute from the far suburbs of rural New Hampshire.
"New Hampshire has that quiet feel that Lake Wylie used to have," she said.
Write to Valerie Bauerlein at email@example.com
Credit: By Valerie Bauerlein | Photographs by Swikar Patel for The Wall Street Journal